Dec 9, 2014

How Could Falling Oil Prices Affect Renewable Energy Growth?

Energy Policy
3 min
Unless you’ve been living under a rock (which, hey, no judgments here), you’ve more than likely heard about the falling price of oil. Oil...

Unless you’ve been living under a rock (which, hey, no judgments here), you’ve more than likely heard about the falling price of oil. Oil, of course, is big business and when big business affected somehow, it doesn’t happen in a vacuum.

One of the most impacted sectors is of course renewable energy. There are those out there who think that a fall in oil prices would mean a fall in renewable energy growth, but that would be oversimplifying things. The relationship between oil and renewable energy is much more complicated than that. 

“Inevitably, there will be some impact because we think the high oil price is a key driver [for] renewable energy,” Flora Chang, an energy analyst at Bernstein Research, told CNBC.

Chang believes that cheaper oil will only potentially delay projects, though, not completely derail them. Remember: the price of renewable energy is falling rapidly too.

“Renewable energy is a technology. In the technology sector, costs always go down,” Bernstein’s mid-November report read. “Fossil fuels are extracted. In extractive industries, costs (almost) always go up. Renewable and fossil fuel cost per unit of energy are now roughly comparable in many places… but heading in opposite directions. New, superior technologies don't split markets with old, inferior technologies.”

Some, such as Lin Boqiang, director of the Energy Economics Research Center at Xiamen University in China, believe this isn’t quite true across the board and countries such as China could see trouble in the renewable energy sector.

“If oil stays at current prices or weakens through the first half of next year,” he told Bloomberg, “the impact on new energy would be massive. Weakening oil prices would hamper the competitiveness of new energy. The government has to subsidize the new energy industry to support its development.”

Despite this fear in China, markets in North America and Europe will likely remain unchanged. Other major energy players might see some affects, but they are expected to be minimal.

“In the Middle East, and to a lesser extent post-Fukushima Japan, there is some relevance,” Pavel Molchanov, a senior research analyst at Raymond James Financial, told The Guardian. But even at prices below today’s forecasts, he added, “solar can compete effectively with diesel-fired generation.”

According to Colin Chilcoat of, this competition isn’t what will hamper renewable energy growth.

“By 2020, utility-scale solar will be competitive with gas-fired power at a wide range of natural gas prices and in all key markets, including low-insolation regions,” he wrote for the CS Monitor. “Wind power is already there. The total LCOE (Levelized Cost of Energy) for onshore wind is cheaper than that of conventional coal as well as natural gas-fired plants with carbon capture and storage.”

What, then, should renewable energy companies be worrying about?

“The biggest threat to renewables growth is not the price of oil or gas, but instead policy and regulatory measures,” Chilcoat claimed. “With the United States’ solar investment tax credit set to expire in 2016, states taking matters into their own hands, and the EU’s own unclear renewable policy future post-2020, investors will have trouble guaranteeing an equitable and predictable return.”

While tackling policy is a whole different debate, what is the answer to the initially posed question? Will the drop in oil prices affect renewable energy? In short: no, probably not.

“Fluctuations in oil prices have little impact on solar or many other renewable energy sources. This is partly why the economic proposition of solar is so compelling, unique and valuable,” Marc van Gerven, vice president of global strategic marketing at First Solar, told The Guardian. “For example, up to 50 percent of the cost of a fossil plant is the expense of the fuel over the life of the plant, while sunlight is essentially free.”

So for now, don’t worry, and enjoy filling up the car for less. 

Share article

Apr 23, 2021

Drax advances biomass strategy with Pinnacle acquisition

Dominic Ellis
2 min
Drax is advancing biomass following Pinnacle acquisition it reported in a trading update

Drax' recently completed acquisition of Pinnacle more than doubles its sustainable biomass production capacity and significantly reduces its cost of production, it reported in a trading update.

The Group’s enlarged supply chain will have access to 4.9 million tonnes of operational capacity from 2022. Of this total, 2.9 million tonnes are available for Drax’s self-supply requirements in 2022, which will rise to 3.4 million tonnes in 2027.

The £424 million acquisition of the Canadian biomass pellet producer supports Drax' ambition to be carbon negative by 2030, using bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS) and will make a "significant contribution" in the UK cutting emissions by 78% by 2035 (click here).

Drax CEO Will Gardiner said its Q1 performance had been "robust", supported by the sale of Drax Generation Enterprise, which holds four CCGT power stations, to VPI Generation.

This summer Drax will undertake maintenance on its CfD(2) biomass unit, including a high-pressure turbine upgrade to reduce maintenance costs and improve thermal efficiency, contributing to lower generation costs for Drax Power Station.

In March, Drax secured Capacity Market agreements for its hydro and pumped storage assets worth around £10 million for delivery October 2024-September 2025.

The limitations on BECCS are not technology but supply, with every gigatonne of CO2 stored per year requiring approximately 30-40 million hectares of BECCS feedstock, according to the Global CCS Institute. Nonetheless, BECCS should be seen as an essential complement to the required, wide-scale deployment of CCS to meet climate change targets, it concludes.

Share article