Paris climate talks reveal Trump card for business
Convened by President Emmanuel Macron of France, United Nations Secretary General Antonio Guterres, and World Bank Group President Jim Yong Kim, the One Planet Summit featured a range of high profile announcements on climate finance issues affecting the energy sector.
These came from a variety of stakeholders, including governments, banks, businesses, and investors focused on financing both the global transition away from fossil fuels and the measures required to adapt to changes already underway caused by global warming. Conspicuous by his country’s absence, President Trump’s withdrawal from the Paris Agreement offered a stark reminder of the challenges ahead.
Overview of the One Planet Summit
Emmanuel Macron warned the One Planet Summit participants: “Think long and hard, if you make a commitment, we will hold you to it.” The pledges made to this year’s commitments represent big actions to be taken in 2018 in three areas: to step up finance for adaption and resilience to climate change, accelerate the transition towards a decarbonised economy and anchor climate issues at the centre of the decisions of business. See the stats below the article.
Implications for the planet
The Paris Agreement aims to keep temperatures from rising more than two degrees Celsius (3.6 degrees Fahrenheit) by the year 2100 (a level scientists believe will help prevent the worst effects of climate change). However, research from the United Nations Environment Program (UNEP) shows current pledges from countries around the world will only restrict temperature rise to 3.2 degrees Celsius (5.8 degrees Fahrenheit).
Implications for the industry
The implications for the energy industry were writ large as a coalition of 225 global investors (including the likes of Allianz, HSBC Global Asset Management and Schroders) signed on for Climate Action 100+. The scheme targets the 100 biggest emitting companies seeking engagement on climate-management issues. The 100, mostly in the oil and gas, transportation and power sectors, will be urged to reduce emissions, ramp their climate governance mechanisms and increase their levels of disclosure.
Allied to this, a coalition of 237 major companies used the Paris talks as a platform to highlight their climate-related credentials. Their number includes the likes of Shell and Total, along with the global mining firms Glencore, Vale and BHP.
In a further bid for effective implementation of the Paris Agreement’s goals, the World Bank announced its pledge to stop financing oil and gas projects after 2019. However, it said consideration would still be given to financing upstream gas in the poorest countries “where there is a clear benefit in terms of energy access for the poor”, and the project fits within the nations’ Paris climate commitments. It also committed to reporting greenhouse gas emissions from the investment projects it finances in key emissions-producing sectors, such as energy, from next year. The World Bank said it will continue to support investments highlighted at the Summit, including accelerating energy efficiency in India and scaling up solar energy in Ethiopia, Pakistan and Senegal among other countries.
Meanwhile, Gallic insurance giant Axa announced plans to divest €2.4bn in coal investments while pledging to quadruple its support of clean energy projects to the tune of €12bn. Other notable EU investment came from BNP Paribas for the Sustainable Finance Facilities programme - a UN environment initiative to develop collaborations between business, NGOs and government departments to raise $10bn for projects tackling renewable energy access, agroforestry, water access and responsible agriculture. BNP Paribas also joined the Breakthrough Energy Coalition, set up by Bill Gates in 2015, to innovate new technologies supporting clean energy and low-carbon with $2bn.
Elsewhere, 23 companies (including EDF, BT, Unilever and the Virgin Group) joined the Powering Past Coal Alliance, boosting its membership to 58. The alliance, initiated by the UK and Canada at COP23, seeks to promote action by governments and business to phase out coal-fired plants which currently account for 40% of global electricity.
Trump’s US withdrawal
The Paris Agreement of 2015 included a provision committing developed countries to provide $100bn of annual funding for climate initiatives beginning in 2020. According to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, reaching that target is far off and took a serious dent when the Trump administration withdrew the US government’s $2bn pledge to the Green Climate Fund (an organisation led by developed countries to finance renewable energy and climate change adaptation projects) in 2016. Speaking last June Trump railed against spending a “vast fortune” on the initiative: “Under the Paris Accord, billions of dollars that ought to be invested right here in America will be sent to the very countries that have taken our factories and our jobs away from us. So think of that!”
However, the LSE’s research director Robert Falkner believes the Paris Agreement will survive US withdrawal, arguing that Trump’s announcement actually reinforced international support for the treaty. “Because it is built on a decentralised system of voluntary mitigation pledges the Paris accord is more resilient to political shocks than Kyoto. As long as other major emitters stick to their mitigation, the Paris process of reviewing progress and renewing pledges will carry on as planned. In any case, the earliest that the US would actually leave the treaty is after the next presidential election in 2020, by which time the political climate in the US may have shifted again.”
While emerging economies have begun to curb fast-rising emissions and global carbon emissions are levelling off, the genuine fear remains Trump’s rejection of Paris could encourage other uncooperative powers to renege on their pledges. However, Falkner remains confident: “After years of investing in energy efficiency and green energy, corporate boardrooms in the US are unlikely to reverse course and embrace outdated fossil fuel energy solutions. As other major economies are increasingly betting on renewable energy and green technologies, leading US companies will want to avoid falling behind in the global race to build the low-carbon economy of the future.”
World leaders are set to re-convene for this year’s talks in the heart of Poland’s coal mining industry. The decision to hold the pivotal 2018 UN climate conference in Katowice has angered some campaigners, but others suggest it offers hope it could symbolise a transition away from fossil fuels.
Poland has traditionally been a reluctant participant in the UN process, necessitated by its status in the EU negotiating bloc. Heavily influenced by its powerful domestic coal industry, it also plays host to one of the European mining industry’s biggest trade fairs. It was revealed last year that Poland was part of a concerted effort by eastern European countries to water down EU laws which, under the climate accord, bind Europe to the promise to reduce emissions by 40% by 2030 through the revision of existing climate laws on renewables, energy efficiency and the flagship Emissions Trading System policy.
However, UNFCCC chair Patricia Espinosa has said that governments were expected to reach “key milestones” at the 2018 conference when countries will come together to take stock of their progress towards targets agreed three years ago in Paris. Experts believe those targets were too weak to avert dangerous climate change so the Polish summit will offer an opportunity to upgrade them. With or without Trump.
The 12 One Planet Summit commitments
Stepping up finance for adaptation and resilience to climate change
1. Responding to extreme events in island states
Rebuilding the Caribbean – mobilisation of $3bn in a public-private partnership within an $8bn investment plan to make the Caribbean the first Climate Smart Zone
2. Protecting land and water against climate change
$300mn for the Land Degradation Neutrality Fund to restore deserted land
Launch of the “Tropical Landscape Financing Facility”
A $650mn financing programme for research to help smallholder farmers adapt to climate change
Creation of the 100 Water and Climate Projects for Africa funding platform
3. Mobilising researchers and young people to work for the climate
$15mn for the One Planet Fellowship for young African and European researchers
Launch of the “European Solidarity Corps” for the climate, with €40mn
4. Public procurement and access for local governments to green financing
“Global Urbis”: creation of a common framework for cities to simplify access to climate financing
Alliance of cities and regions for low-carbon public procurement
Accelerating the transition towards a decarbonised economy
5. Zero Emissions Target
“Towards Carbon Neutrality” coalition: 16 countries and 32 cities commit to reach carbon neutrality by 2050
Launch of the “Paris Collaborative on Green Budgeting”
Creation of a Climate Observatory in Space
6. Sectoral shift towards a decarbonised economy
Powering Past Coal Alliance
Launch of a conversion fund by the European Commission for coal-intensive regions International Solar Alliance
7. Zero-Pollution transport
Eight countries and 10 partners commit to decarbonized transport and clean mobility solutions
34 countries pledge to reduce maritime transport emissions
Partnership of eight western US states for electric vehicles
8. Vers un prix du carbone compatible avec l’accord de Paris
Commitments by several countries to a more significant carbon price
Launch of Carbon pricing for the Americas
Announcement by China of the unification of its carbon market
Call by businesses for carbon pricing
Anchoring climate issues at the centre of the decisions of finance and its actors
9. Actions of central banks and businesses
Commitment of 200+ businesses support the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosure (TCFD)
10+ central banks and supervisors launch the network “Greening the Financial System”
10. International mobilisation of development banks
More than 30 public development banks commit to align their financing with the Paris Agreement
11. Commitment by sovereign funds
Creation of the working group One Planet Sovereign Wealth Funds - six of the largest sovereign wealth funds create an ESG framework (environmental, social and governance) to guide their investment decision
12. Mobilising institutional investors
Climate Action 100+ coalition (brings together 225 major institutional investors representing more than $26trn in managed assets to coordinate their actions as regards the 100 highest-emitting public companies)
$1bn Energy Breakthrough Coalition: investing in breakthrough technologies
Coalition of 10-plus philanthropists working to improve climate action finance and to develop new investment mechanisms
- TerraPraxis & Microsoft team up to decarbonise coal plantsSustainability
- Israel’s GenCellEnergy launches off-grid EV chargingSustainability
- Shell Egypt, EGAS & Petronas contract Bechtel-led coalitionSustainability
- QatarEnergy awards US$631m EPC contract for IC Solar projectRenewable Energy